Basket strainers and Y-Strainers each have design parameters that will affect their success in specific applications. Taking a little time to identify application specifics will ensure that you select a strainer that will perform as expected in your piping system.
The first thing to determine is the flow rate. Any flow rate over 150 GPM will most likely require a basket strainer because of pressure drop considerations. Strainers are usually sized so that their start up pressure drop is no greater than 2 PSI, with a line velocity not to exceed 8 FPS. On a per size basis, basket strainers exhibit less pressure loss than Y-Strainers. On this website, under Product Downloads, there is a Pressure Loss Calculator.
The next application parameter is difficult to determine, but is important. You need to know just how dirty the process media gets. Y-Strainer screens are smaller in dirt holding capacity than the strainer baskets used in basket strainers. So, in a given application, a basket strainer will go longer between cleanings than a Y-Strainer will.
This is also important because cleaning the screen of a Y-Strainer can be a messy affair compared to a basket strainer. Remember: the strainer leg of the Y-Strainer must be below the pipeline, pointing down, to trap the debris. This means that when the cap is removed to clean the screen of the Y-Strainer, be prepared for any fluid trapped in the strainer to drain out immediately. Depending on the process media, and the location of the strainer, this can be a significant problem.
This problem doesn't exist with a basket strainer. The hand removable cover of a Hayward basket strainer is on top. After making sure there is no line pressure, just screw off the cover and lift out the basket to clean or replace it.
Metal Y-Strainers sometimes have a blow-down connection on the cap to permit cleaning the screen without removing the cap. This is not recommended with a plastic Y-Strainer because the hole in the cap would weaken the strainer and affect its pressure rating.
So, if the application requires infrequent cleaning and the process media is environmentally safe, a Y-Strainer should work. If the opposite is true and the strainer will be cleaned often and the fluid is less than friendly, a basket strainer is the answer. If in doubt, select the basket strainer every time. It may cost a bit more but will stay in service longer between cleanouts, and it will be easier to clean.
If the application requires that the system has to run continuously and cannot be shut down, then the only real choice is a duplex basket strainer.
Size of the perforations in the screen or basket is another consideration. Hayward plastic Y-Strainer screens are only available in 1/32" perforation. Hayward basket strainers, depending on size, come with 1/32", 1/16", 1/8" or 3/16" perforation plastic baskets. Stainless steel baskets and screens are available with perforations from 40 microns up to 1/2", for both basket and Y-Strainers.
Installation orientation of the strainer must also be considered. If a vertical installation is planned, a Y-Strainer is the one that will work. Y-Strainers can be installed either vertically or horizontally. A basket strainer must be installed horizontally.
Whether you choose a Y Strainer or basket strainer, a spare basket or screen should always be purchased at the same time. A spare screen or basket makes clean-out easier. Just remove the dirty one and install the clean spare one. The line is back in service quicker and the dirty screen can be cleaned or replaced later.
And remember, nothing is quite as useless as a strainer without a basket or screen. If the basket breaks or gets lost or damaged, the line is out of service until a new one is located, purchased and installed. Having a spare on hand avoids this downtime problem.
Y-Strainer or Basket Strainer? A quick look at your application parameters and you'll be able to select the right one.
